Account of Meeting with First Appealate Authority for "Bathroom Renovation RTI"

In continuation with RTI on Bathroom Renovation

There were atleast six people with me to talk including FAA(First Appealate Authority-Registrar- Sandeep Chatterji), PIO(Jit Singh), Someone from IHA etc. Majorly the complete talk was lead by FAA. These are the lines, I remember-

me: Excuse me, Sir can I ask my friend to come in

FAA: no, only Kapil can come, who are you?

me: I am kapil. can i take a min to tell my friend to go?

FAA: ok

After coming back to the meeting...

FAA: Which center?

me: computer science.

FAA: doing BTech?

me: no masters, Mtech.

FAA: you live in periyar

me: ya

PIO: 149

FAA: Yes, Kapil do you get all the replies?

me: May be, but i am not able to understand.

FAA: let us both help each other to understand the matter

me:ok

FAA: lets start your questions one by one where is your RTI.

FAA: your first question "Please give the list of parameters and(or) reasons bathrooms were found to be in need of renovation."

FAA: were bathrooms were all right? what were the reasons, Kapil?

me: my reply does not matter, i want your reply, I mean JNU's reply

FAA: Have you got reply from IHA?

me: I think I have, please let me see.. No, I dont have this.

FAA: but you wrote that you don't need it, earlier, didn't you?

me: ya, i write. but this tells that- "because of students' repersentations you started", which cannot be the right reason

JNU cannot do it just because of studnts' repersentation

FAA: But, for me it means that you don't need this answer

(Teaching me..that you should never say no to anything coming without cost ... bla bla to show me that i am in fix now)

me: ok lets come to other questions.

[few questions are answered by CPWD so i repeatedly asked to skip that]

me: there are some funny replies see questions 9, 10

Q9. List all parameter, for which official checked the state of bathrooms and found them ready to use

Answer by CPWD: All necessary parameters were checked during execution of work for renovation of bathrooms.

FAA: they have answered correctly, you asked parameters they have said all parameters, if you want detailed you must have given some examples

me: can you transfer my first appeal to CPWD?

FAA: no this cannot be done.

me: Q10 Does some quality standards were maintained in renovation of bathrooms? if so please tell.

Answer by CPWD: Yes, all quality standards were maintained in renovation of bathrooms.

FAA: this is also perfectly correct, you must have asked what standard you are talking about if you want more. They have given you exactly what you asked they are not interested in giving you more information. for detailed information you must directly ask CPWD with proper questions, you must specify what you need.like BEA standard or what?

me: since the time may have passed to apply first appeal at CPWD can you give me any letter or any way to proceed with CPWD?

PIO: we can give a letter. right sir? (asking FAA)

FAA: no, we cannot. you may file fresh RTI with CPWD refering this RTI.